Mediating commitments

Ian Macduff

Resum


This paper explores the implications of one aspect of intercultural theory –the dimension of power distance– in order to comment on the nature of commitments in the mediation process. The familiar model of Western mediation assumes that parties can identify core interests and negotiate around those, through prioritising, trading and balancing. At the heart of our thinking about commitments are our ideas about agency, autonomy, and accountability. However, a core implication of empirical work on power distance suggests that expectations of deference may lead some participants to avoid direct decision-making responsibility and, rather than work towards commitments, to act on the commitments or obligations they already have. Thus, low-power distance culture members are more able and willing to make commitments; high-power distance culture members are more constrained by having commitments. Whereas the Western model of negotiation and mediation addresses the means to reach commitments (the legitimacy of which stems from the choices the autonomous agents make), the norms that shape conduct in high-PD cultures are those the reflect having commitments and obligations (the legitimacy of which derives from antecedent relationships).

Paraules clau


negotiation, mediation, iintercultural theory, power distance, commitment

Text complet:

PDF (English)


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7238/joc.v0i1.935

Copyright (c)

Journal of Conflictology és una revista impulsada pel Campus per la Pau de la Universitat Oberta de Catalunya

Creative Commons
Els textos publicats en aquesta revista estan subjectes –llevat que s'indiqui el contrari– a una llicència de Reconeixement 3.0 Espanya de Creative Commons. Podeu copiar-los, distribuir-los, comunicar-los públicament i fer-ne obres derivades sempre que reconegueu els crèdits de les obres (autoria, nom de la revista, institució editora) de la manera especificada pels autors o per la revista. La llicència completa es pot consultar a http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/es/deed.ca .